More Than Just Faces in the Crowd

A look at the stunning number of Williams student-athletes, alumni and coaches whose accomplishments landed them on the pages of Sports Illustrated magazine.

By Brooks Clark

Each week from 1956 until 2020, Sports Illustrated cited six “Faces in the Crowd.” These were amateur athletes and coaches, young and old, from all corners of the nation, who achieved something exemplary. During that period—before the magazine’s circulation dropped to once per month and the number of people recognized dwindled—at least 49 Williams athletes, coaches and alumni received the recognition.

Many Eph “Faces” came after an NCAA Division III (DIII) or New England Small College Athletic Conference (NESCAC) championship. But even considering the college’s many titles over the years, the sheer number of  Williams people recognized by the magazine stands out.

For this article, we gathered our noted student and alumni Ephs’ write-ups and photographs from Sports Illustrated. And we asked them to share what they’re up to now and to reflect on how their athletic experiences at Williams impacted their lives. The resulting stories, which appear here in chronological order by the year they were originally published, show the impact of Williams’ unique combination of academic and athletic rigor.

Learn more about the coaches who appeared in “Faces” in “Seven to Remember.” You can also read about the man behind the college’s robust “Faces in the Crowd” numbers—Sports Information Director Dick Quinn—in the accompanying story “A Familiar Face.”

Even More Faces in the Crowd!

Thanks to all who have reached out and added to our list of Ephs appearing in Sports Illustrated’s “Faces in the Crowd.” Among them are: 

Wendell Chesnut ’88, who was featured in the April 25, 1988 issue. The first Black All-America in squash, he led Williams to a 12-7 record and a 10th-place national ranking in his final season with the team;

Rodney Geier ’75, who was listed in “Faces” in 1970 when he was attending high school. A standout football player at Williams, he was co-captain of the 1974 team and credited the coaching staff, including legends Dick Farley and Renzie Lamb, for their success;

Tim Walsh ’86, who was featured in the March 17, 1986 issue. It was noted at the time that Walsh, a 5 10” senior guard on the basketball team, set a school career scoring mark of 1,626 points, averaging 18.4 points per game; 

And also Greg Zaff ’84, who was featured in 1983. The “Faces” entry credits Zaff as “believed to be the first player in four years to have been named an All-America in both squash and tennis” in Division III. 

Have another name for us? Email [email protected] with the details!

Gordon Pritchett
1962 Gordon Pritchett ’63
Soccer
“At Williams I developed a self-confidence that transferred to my later athletic endeavors and to my professional life as a teacher, coach, mentor and leader.”
Katherine (Eckrich) Oster
1981 Katherine (Eckrich) Oster ’85
Swimming & Diving
“It was not ‘Swim your best’ but ‘We need this, so go get it.’ We wildly cheered for each other.”
Ted Rogers
1990 Ted Rogers ’91
Football
“Coach Farley was a football genius and had strict processes; we learned attention to detail, discipline, accountability and grit.”
Lindley (Hall) van der Linde
1991 Lindley (Hall) van der Linde ’93
Nordic Skiing
“I always felt supported, encouraged and motivated by my coach and now friend for life Bud Fisher.”
Patty Conte
1992 Patty (Althoff) Conte '92
Swimming & Diving
“Being coached by Mandy Glenner Hixon gave me the skills and confidence to be able to coach, myself. … I loved making practice fun for kids and young adults and enjoyed the mentoring process for high school students.”
Marc Siegel
1994 Marc Siegel ’96
Ice Hockey
“Hockey at Williams taught me accountability to my colleagues and responsibility to the business.”
Jeremie Perry
1995 Jeremie Perry ’96
Cross-Country
“Coach Pete Farwell’s ’78 willingness to tailor training to each of our runners’ needs was paramount to both my success and the success of the team.”
Ethan Brooks
1996 Ethan Brooks '96
Track & Field, Football
Derek Sasaki-Scanlon
1997 Derek Sasaki-Scanlon ’98
Track & Field
“My enjoyment of multi-event competition planted the seeds for my entrepreneurial journey.”
Erin Kate (Anderson) Pritchett
1999 Erin Kate (Anderson) Prichett '00
Swimming & Diving
“Competing as an intercollegiate swimmer taught me the power of perseverance—all those early morning (and afternoon!) practices, plus fierce competition while balancing academics.”
Courtney Benningson Batliner
1999 Courtney Bennigson Batliner '01
Triathlon
“I treasure my WWXC team experience and teammates.”
Molly (Wasserman) Meyers
2001 Molly (Wasserman) Meyers ’04
Ice Hockey
“The [operating room] is run like a team, with each person … serving a valuable role that has to be executed for the success of the patient.”
Felix Grossman
2001 Felix “Buster” Grossman ’56
Swimming & Diving
“Sports are always a part of my story.”
Joe Reardon
2002 Joe Reardon ’04
Football
“Honored to be on the last team that took the field for [Coach] Dick Farley, ending his career in the only way possible, ‘The Walk,’ after beating Amherst.”
Healy Thompson
2002 Healy Thompson ’03
Track & Field
“I had to give my best at practice or competition and then set that aside while giving my best in the classroom.”
Josh Lefkowitz
2002 Josh Lefkowitz ’02
Tennis
Coach Dave Johnson “brought an intellect, a quiet competitive intensity and a humble team-first mentality that … played a critical role in my growth.”
Shoshanna Clark Stewart
2002 Shoshana (Clark) Stewart ’02
Crew
“I had an extraordinary coach, Justin Moore, who challenged us to simply work harder than we ever had before but with a deep sense of team work ethic and commitment. And my astrophysics professors and peers showed me the world beyond Williams, from star clusters far away to my very first trip abroad to view the solar eclipse in Zambia.”
Caroline Cretti
2003 Caroline Cretti ’06
Cross-Country
“Competing at Williams showed me how focusing on other aspects of yourself—your other interests, studies, friends and family—can make you an even better athlete and more able to achieve in your area of focus.”
Michael Crotty
2003 Michael Crotty Jr. ’04
Basketball
A Winter Study course on coaching and leadership with basketball coach Dave Paulsen “impacted my decision to become a coach in my life after Williams.”
Jenn (Campbell) McKechnie
2003 Jenn (Campbell) McKechnie '05
Track & Field
“[Coach] Pete Farwell ’73 … cared about the success of every single runner, celebrating [personal records] across the board.”
Nick Ryder
2004 Nick Ryder
Golf
Lindsay Payne
2005 Lindsay Payne ’06
Swimming & Diving
On coaching Williams swimming for a month in 2023: “It was awesome to be back on deck but from a different perspective.”
Amanda Nicholson Bergold
2007 Amanda (Nicholson) Bergold ’09
Swimming & Diving
“Swimming can be an individual sport; I started to do better when I thought of it more collectively.”
Laura Sinnenberg
2008 Lauren Sinnenberg ’10
Soccer
“The greatest influence … is that Williams women’s soccer is how I met my wife, Tyler Rainer ’11, who is the best person I have ever known.”
Joey Lye
2009 Joey Lye ’09
Softball
Playing softball and ice hockey “allowed me to follow my passions, overcome challenges and build relationships that will last a lifetime.”
Logan Todhunter
2009 Logan Todhunter ’12
Swimming & Diving
“I am a better provider to my patients and a better person because I was a member of this team. My coaches, especially Coaches Steve Kuster, Katelyn Brochu and Dave Polen—they showed me every day what it meant to be a leader.”
Ryan Malo
2010 Ryan Malo ’11
Wrestling
“My path to Williams as a transfer student was non-traditional. My teammates welcomed me with open arms, and we stay in touch to this day. … Although I never competed for [current coach Scott Honecker], we speak almost daily, and it’s a lot of fun to follow the success of the current team.”
Darren Hartwell
2010 Darren Hartwell ’13
Football
“Shout-out to [wide receivers coach] Marshall Creighton ’02. … One of his favorite sayings was, ‘Don’t be afraid to be great,’ and he played a key role in helping me find confidence in myself on the field so I could realize my full potential.”
Bryan Chow
2011 Bryan Chow '13
Tennis
“My experience as a member of the Williams tennis team taught me the importance of teamwork and collaboration, and these essential lessons have directly affected my personal and professional life.”
Trey Meyer
2011 Trey Meyer ’13
Tennis
“Being a part of a team has greatly impacted me, and I now strive to bring that same team mentality to my career.”
Chiara Del Piccolo
2012 Chiara Del Piccolo ’14
Track & Field
Nicki Kimball
2012 Nikki Kimball ’93
Ultramarathon
“Several of my teammates are lifelong friends, with bonds solidified at Williams through our team Sunday long runs. … Getting to run with Pam (Proffitt) Smith ’96 and Greg Crowther ’95 at some of the world’s most competitive races helped keep the Eph athletic connection alive well past my graduation.”
Pam (Proffitt) Smith
2013 Pam (Proffitt) Smith ’96
Ultramarathon
“I really came into my own as a person through running at Williams College. That is where I found my sense of belonging and made my closest friends.”
Sarah Thompson
2015 Sarah Thompson ’15
Swimming & Diving
“The early mornings and grueling workouts built up my resilience, but it was the moments in between—the shared laughter, the hard-fought races and the unshakable bond with my teammates—that were the most impactful and … continue to color how I approach life—with grit, adaptability and a lasting appreciation for the power of showing up for others, no matter the lane or phase of life.”
Cordelia Chan
2015 Cordelia Chan '19
Golf
“Golf is a metaphor for life: You can’t let your highs be too high or your lows be too low.”
Julie Raventos Knohr
2016 Juli Raventos Knohr ’18
Tennis
Linda Shin
2016 Linda Shin ’18
Tennis
Ben Lin
2017 Ben Lin ’17
Swimming & Diving
Peter Hale
2017 Peter Hale ’17
Track & Field
“Coach Pete Farwell used to say, ‘Less push, more flow.’ … I’ve been in some high-pressure situations post-college where that mantra’s popped into my head.”
Olivia Barnhill
2017 Olivia Barnhill ’19
Soccer
“I strive to bring that team mentality to my career. Working to accomplish goals, meet deadlines, and produce excellent work has always been better when you're doing it not just for yourself but the people around you.”
Tobias Muellers
2018 Tobias Muellers ’18
Track & Field
“Whenever I’m faced with a challenge in my work, personal life or athletic endeavors, I know that I have what I need to see it through.”
Sam Goldenring
2019 Sam Goldenring ’20
Golf
“Being an athlete at Williams taught me it’s OK to ask for help and how to lean into my support system.”